Sunday, March 18, 2018

Speaker wars

Of course there is no war at all, except that which has been in my head over which speakers to use in our office. I have switched between having a HomePod in the office to having my Harman Kardons in there... and back and forth a number of times.

Most recently, we have one HomePod in the living room, one in the bedroom, and the Harman Kardons in the office. This has been working rather well. Shawna has been using the HomePods in the bedroom and living room and enjoying them.

So today I was doing some "audio tests" and came to another decision (a similar thing happened the last time I did audio tests). For those who don't know, these audio tests are what we refer to around here as "music appreciation hour". That happens on occasion when I am left unsupervised for more than an hour or two.

Anyway, my conclusion today was... while the Harmon Kardons might outcrank the HomePod... there are more things to consider.

Perhaps the Harman Kardons are superior. I don't even really know for sure. I do know that all the feedback I've read about the HomePod talks about the excellent sound. Even the people who don't like it say it sounds great. So I simply might be mistaken in thinking the Harman Kardons sound better. I honestly suspect that is true. I mean how could a $150 set of speakers outperform a $350 one that by all accounts is "great sounding for the price"?

So my decision... is to double-down. I am going to buy a third HomePod to use in the office. We will essentially have one in each room of the house. My OCD likes things being uniform. Three matching speakers. Yay! And Siri in every room to control our HomeKit devices.

So the Harman Kardons are back in the box in the garage where they will likely stay. If they are truly the better-sounding speakers... then oh well. Regardless of which speakers actually sound better, I am fully determined at this point that the HomePod will suffice. It may not be true hi-fi, but it's "good-enough-fi".

I did a similar thing when I shed my $2,000 front room stereo in favor of a sound bar. Being content with less is a good thing. And if I can't crank the HomePod loud enough so the neighbors can hear it, well that's ok. I probably shouldn't be doing that anyway right?

No comments:

Post a Comment